Business cases for legal technology tend to fail in the same meeting. The slide says reviews get faster and lawyers get more productive; the CFO asks where the numbers came from; the answer is another company, another contract mix, another year. This post gives you no numbers. It gives you a model, the measurements that fill it and the questions finance will ask, so the case is built from your own legal function.
In short
- Measure before you model. A two-week log of where counsel time goes on each contract type is worth more than any benchmark, including any we could give you.
- Value comes from four places. Counsel hours on preparation, cycle time to signature, overflow sent to outside counsel, and the leakage after signing: renewals that roll over unnoticed and obligations nobody chases.
- Cost is more than the licence. Encoding the playbook, connecting the contract repository, change management and the running cost of models belong in the case from the start.
- The sensitive variable is review effort. How long a lawyer spends checking a prepared matter, rather than preparing it, decides most of the outcome. Test the case against a pessimistic value.
Start with a time sample
Pick a representative fortnight. For a sample of matters of each common type — NDAs, supplier MSAs, SaaS order forms, statements of work — ask counsel to log minutes against a few coarse activities. Honesty matters more than precision.
| Activity | Preparation or judgement? | Measure |
|---|---|---|
| Triage: type, paper, personal data, what is missing | Preparation | Minutes per matter |
| Finding and reading the clauses | Preparation | Minutes per draft |
| Comparing with the company’s positions | Mostly preparation | Minutes per draft |
| Cross-checks: exhibits, DPA, parent agreement | Preparation | Minutes per draft, and how often something is missing |
| Drafting redlines and the cover note | Preparation | Minutes per draft |
| Re-reading revised drafts | Preparation | Minutes per round, and rounds per matter |
| Deciding what to accept; escalating to the General Counsel | Judgement | Minutes per matter |
| Approval | Judgement | Minutes per matter, and days waiting |
Alongside the sample, pull four numbers from your systems: matters opened per year by type, median days from request to signature, the share of matters sent to outside counsel and what that costs, and the number of signed contracts that auto-renew. These are the baseline the case is measured against.
The model
Write the case as formulas with named inputs, so finance can change any input and see the effect. For
each contract type t:
# inputs you measure N_t matters per year of type t P_t preparation minutes per matter today # all rounds J_t judgement minutes per matter today R_t minutes to check a prepared matter # estimate, then measure in a pilot C fully loaded cost per counsel minute # counsel capacity released minutes_today = Σ_t N_t × (P_t + J_t) minutes_after = Σ_t N_t × (R_t + J_t) capacity_value = (minutes_today − minutes_after) × C # overflow brought back in house (only if capacity is actually redeployed) O outside counsel spend on routine review today share_back share of that work the released capacity can absorb overflow_value = O × share_back # after signing: renewals and obligations A auto-renewing contracts per year miss share whose notice deadline passed without a decision # from a look-back would_end share of those the owner would have ended or renegotiated V_r average annual value of such a contract renewal_value = A × miss × would_end × V_r × share_recoverable annual_value = capacity_value + overflow_value + renewal_value
Every input is yours. Leave out any line you can’t measure; the case should survive without it.
Where each input comes from
The one input you can’t measure today, R_t, is what the pilot is for.
The renewal look-back
Take last year’s auto-renewing contracts and ask, for each, whether anyone made a decision before
the notice deadline. The deadline is the end of the term less the notice period stated in the executed
copy; on a twelve-month term with ninety days’ notice it falls three months before the end. For
the ones that renewed by default, ask the owner whether they would have ended or renegotiated. This is
the only honest source for miss and would_end.
Cycle time
Faster signature has value when revenue or an operational start date waits on the contract — a sales order form, a supplier the plant needs. Model it only for those types, and only with a figure the business owner will stand behind.
The cost side
| Cost | What to include |
|---|---|
| Licence and hosting | The platform and its hosting |
| Encoding the playbook | Counsel time to write positions, fallback language and approvers for the contract types in scope, and to test them against recent drafts |
| Connecting sources | The intake queue, the contract repository and its executed copies |
| Change management | Training, a period of dual running, and updating approval policy into controls |
| Model running cost | Per-agent spend is recorded on each step; with the model off the agents run on rules, so this line can be zero |
| Ongoing ownership | Someone in legal operations keeps the playbook and the controls current |
Run a pilot that measures R
High-volume, mostly counterparty paper: supplier MSAs and SaaS order forms are typical.
Positions, fallback language, severity, approver.
The agents prepare; counsel checks and decides as usual.
Minutes from opening the prepared matter to a decision: this is R_t.
How often counsel accepts what the agents prepared, by agent and action.
Re-run the model with measured values, including a pessimistic R_t.
For the General Counsel
The case rests on your own time sample and look-back, so you can defend every input. The renewal line is often the one a CFO understands first.
Keep the risk benefits — consistent positions, DPA checks, four-eyes approval — out of the arithmetic and state them plainly beside it.
For legal operations
You own the measurements: the time sample, the pilot log and the repository look-back.
For the board
The question is not whether contract review can be faster but what the legal team does with the time, and what the company stops losing after signing.
No borrowed numbers
We deliberately give no benchmark figures here. A saving measured at another company, on another contract mix, will not survive your CFO’s first question; a saving measured on your own matters will.
Build the case from your own matters, and let the pilot fill in the one number you can’t know yet.
Preparation minutes, judgement minutes, outside counsel overflow and renewals missed: all measurable before you buy anything. Checking time is measurable in a month.